Boox.Expert

A Case for Openness Versus Exclusion in America

By Brian Duncan, Stephen J. Trejo

Jordan Jimenez Avatar
By Jordan Jimenez
Published on: 2025-01-12

Immigration has always been central to America’s identity, shaping its culture and communities through the blending of traditions and ideas. As policies increasingly lean toward protectionism, this article argues for inclusivity, drawing on history to reaffirm that the nation’s greatest strength lies in its diversity and openness.

Vaping Image

America has always been shaped by the people who arrive on its shores, bringing with them their traditions, hopes, and aspirations. From its earliest days, the country has thrived as a place where different cultures converge, creating something larger than the sum of its parts. Immigration is not just part of America’s history—it’s central to its identity. Generations of newcomers have helped build its cities, define its values, and expand its understanding of what it means to belong.

Yet, the process of blending into a new society is as complex as it is transformative. For those who arrive as children, the challenges and opportunities of growing up between two worlds often shape not only their own identities but those of their descendants. As they learn new customs, languages, and ways of life, the connection to their cultural roots can weaken, giving way to a new, hybrid sense of self that reflects both where they came from and where they are now. This evolution is as much a story of adaptation as it is a reflection of America’s ongoing journey as a place defined by diversity.

For immigrant families, this transformation often begins with subtle changes in daily life. Children who arrive at a young age are immersed in their new environment at a formative time. They may grow up speaking English as their primary language, surrounded by peers whose experiences feel different from their parents’ but identical to their own. School becomes a powerful driver of assimilation, as these children navigate a world where fitting in often means adapting to the dominant culture. Over time, this adaptation can loosen ties to their heritage, especially when reinforced by the cultural influences of future generations.

Intermarriage further accelerates this blending of identities. When families grow to include spouses from different ethnic backgrounds, their children often inherit a multifaceted sense of self. Rather than identifying with one heritage exclusively, they reflect a combination of both, creating a new layer of cultural diversity. While this may result in a weaker connection to a single ancestral identity, it also enriches the American fabric, fostering greater understanding and unity across communities.

This is not to say that something valuable isn’t lost along the way. Language, in particular, often struggles to survive the shift between generations. Many second- and third-generation children find themselves unable to speak the language of their grandparents, severing a direct link to their cultural past. Traditions may also fade, especially those tied to religious or community practices that are less prominent in mainstream American life. Yet, what remains is a reimagined identity—one that bridges the past and the present, carrying forward the spirit of their ancestors while embracing the possibilities of the future.

The implications of this evolution extend beyond individual families. As demographic shifts reshape the country, so too does the cultural landscape of entire cities and regions. The contributions of immigrant communities are evident in the foods we eat, the holidays we celebrate, and the ways we think about the world. Cities like Los Angeles, Houston, and Chicago owe much of their character to generations of immigrants whose stories are etched into their neighborhoods. The blending of identities is not just about assimilation; it’s about transformation—turning local communities into reflections of the global world.

As President-elect Trump prepares to take office on January 20, 2025, the national conversation around immigration has shifted once again. The rhetoric of protectionism and populism has fueled policies aimed at restricting the flow of immigrants and narrowing the definition of who belongs in America. These measures, rooted in the fear of outsiders and a desire to safeguard an imagined sense of cultural purity, stand in stark contrast to the nation’s history.

America was not built on the ideals of exclusion but on the promise of opportunity. From the arrival of the first immigrants at Ellis Island to the waves of newcomers who have enriched communities across the country, the story of the United States has always been one of inclusion. Ellis Island itself became a symbol of this promise—a place where people from all walks of life came seeking a better future, ready to contribute to a nation that offered hope and possibility.

Restricting immigration in the name of protectionism denies the fundamental truth that diversity is not a threat—it is an asset. Throughout history, immigrants have driven innovation, revitalized communities, and strengthened the cultural fabric of this country. Policies that close doors and build walls ignore the evidence that the blending of cultures leads to growth, not decay. They also risk undermining the very principles that have defined America as a beacon of freedom and opportunity for generations.

The story of immigration is, at its core, the story of America’s resilience. Each wave of immigrants has brought new ideas, energy, and perspectives, enriching the nation while adapting to its ever-changing identity. As we face these new challenges, we must remember that America has never been about building walls—it has been about opening doors.

What makes this country remarkable is its ability to grow from the contributions of those who come here, to adapt and redefine itself with each new generation. To turn away from that now would not only be a betrayal of our history but a denial of our future. The strength of America lies in its diversity, its capacity to embrace change, and its willingness to see immigrants not as threats, but as essential threads in the fabric of the nation.

As the winds of policy shift, let us not forget the ideals that have carried this country through centuries of growth and change. America is at its best when it is inclusive, when it builds bridges instead of barriers, and when it sees in every immigrant the potential for something greater. This is the just America, and it is the America worth fighting for.

Read the Original Paper Download PDF